An open or closed case?

Credit: iStock Jonathan Christian Photography

In the first of a two-part series, Stuart Crisp, UK manager of Advanced Drainage Systems (ADS), considers the case for open or closed bottom below ground attenuation structures and how high groundwater can influence design.

The starting point for designing a below-ground attenuation structure is whether the system can have an open bottom (and sides) to facilitate infiltration, or needs to be lined so collected rainwater is passed downstream to a water body or storm sewer via an outlet. Closely related is the question of what happens when groundwater rises around the installation.

Open-bottom systems are generally preferred where site conditions and regulations allow infiltration. They allow stored stormwater to discharge through the underlying soil, providing treatment through the subsoil and potentially adding a volume safety factor based on the soil’s infiltration capacity. Where infiltration cannot be achieved, for example where the groundwater level precludes any infiltration or the soil has insufficient permeability, a suitable liner can convert the infiltration system into a sealed attenuation facility.

That distinction introduces different hydraulic and geotechnical considerations. In a sealed system, the designer must manage both the water retained within the structure and the groundwater acting outside it. High groundwater can generate hydrostatic uplift beneath a lined structure and, unless sufficient resistance is provided, can result in flotation, causing displacement and instability of the installation and surrounding infrastructure.

ADS Technical Note 6.50 (TN 6.50) identifies viable means of creating watertight attenuation for the StormTech arch-shaped system. For adoption by a water company in England, a lined attenuation system is usually required, where a defined flow path is needed to meet the legal definition of a sewer.

The liner is only part of the hydraulic design. TN 6.50 recommends adequate high-flow protection so peak flow can be passed without overtopping the liner. The weir and associated freeboard should ensure that the maximum water level remains below the liner crest. Depending on the design, this can be achieved through an upstream bypass or downstream overflow arrangement.

Groundwater should be treated as a primary design input for closed-bottom systems. Levels are often highest in winter, but seasonal behaviour varies, and groundwater rebound can cause levels to rise after abstraction ceases. Designing only against normal or currently observed groundwater conditions may therefore underestimate the maximum uplift condition.

Where groundwater rises above the base of a sealed tank, the upward pressure is effectively hydrostatic buoyancy. The critical issue is not simply the nominal weight of the tank. TN 6.50 notes that an arch-shaped system can be heavier than the buoyant force overall, due to the amount of embedment stone used to install the StormTech system, while still experiencing a limiting stability condition in which buoyant pressure exceeds the resistance pressure directly beneath the chambers. In part two, we will consider designing against flotation.

New Civil Engineer
November 2026